Precision of Humpback Whale Migrations Puzzles Scientists


Satellite tracking of 16 humpback whales migrating across the oceans between 2003 and 2010 revealed that the cetaceans can swim legs of their journeys of more than 4,000 miles with unswerving accuracy, despite weather and ocean currents. Most of the whales maintained almost dead-straight courses during their seasonal migrations, often deviating by less than one degree and never more than about five degrees.

The findings, published in the Royal Society’s journal Biology Letters (Horton, T., Holdaway, R., Zerbini, A., Hauser, N., Garrigue, C., et al. [published online before print April 20, 2011] Straight as an arrow: humpback whales swim constant course tracks during long-distance migration, doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2011.0279) have led scientists to suspect that the whales navigate using a combination of the sun’s position, Earth’s magnetism, and even star maps to guide their journeys. According to the abstract, “Humpback whale seasonal migrations, spanning greater than 6500 km of open ocean, demonstrate remarkable navigational precision despite following spatially and temporally distinct migration routes. Satellite-monitored radio tag-derived humpback whale migration tracks in both the South Atlantic and South Pacific include constant course segments of greater than 200 km, each spanning several days of continuous movement. The whales studied here maintain these directed movements, often with better than 1° precision, despite the effects of variable sea-surface currents. Such remarkable directional precision is difficult to explain by established models of directional orientation, suggesting that alternative compass mechanisms should be explored.”

In conclusion, the article states: “Here, we offer several insights into humpback whale migratory orientation. First, humpback whales commonly follow highly directional headings with extreme precision over large expanses of open ocean, despite the effects of sea-surface currents, bathymetry and weather. Second, constant course oceanic movements require correction for passive displacement using an exogenous spatial reference frame and orientation cues. Third, although our findings suggest that humpback whale navigation is compatible with ‘goal orientation’ using a map and compass system, it seems unlikely that individual magnetic and solar orientation cues can, in isolation, explain the extreme navigational precision achieved by humpback whales. The relatively slow movements of humpback whales, combined with their clear ability to navigate with extreme precision over long distances, present outstanding opportunities to explore alternative mechanisms of migratory orientation based on empirical analysis of track data.”

Image 1 for article titled "Precision of Humpback Whale Migrations Puzzles Scientists"
The humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) is a species of baleen whale. One of the larger rorqual species, adults range in length from 12–16 m (39–52 ft) and weigh approximately 36,000 kg (79,000 lb). Annual migrations of up to 25,000 kilometres (16,000 mi) are typical, making it one of the mammal’s best-traveled species (Wikipedia: Humpback whale)

Image 2 for article titled "Precision of Humpback Whale Migrations Puzzles Scientists"
Satellite tag-derived southward migration track maps for seven South Atlantic humpback whales tagged off the coast of Brazil in (a) 2003 (circles) and 2005 (triangles), (b) 2008 (inverted triangles) and 2009 (circles) and nine South Pacific humpback whales and (c) tagged off the coasts of Rarotonga, Cook Islands and New Caledonia in 2007 (circles). Constant course track segments are indicated by the larger symbols. Segment labels (A–b) correspond with table 1. White arrows represent sea-surface current vectors with velocities proportional to the white 1 km h−1 scale bar shown. The generalized position and direction of the approximately 1 km h−1 Antarctic circum-polar current (ACC) are shown by the black arrow in (a) and (b). Magnetic declination isogonics (yellow lines) and magnetic inclination isoclinics (white dashed lines) as of 1 January 2005 are shown for reference.

Please follow and like us: