A Species of Tiger Moth Is the Only Animal that Can Jam the Sonar of a Predator


“When it comes to saving its own hide, the tiger moth can predict the future. A new study by researchers at Wake Forest University shows Bertholdia trigona, a species of tiger moth found in the Arizona desert, can tell if an echo-locating bat is going to attack it well before the predator swoops in for the kill – making the intuitive, tiny-winged insect a master of self-preservation. A bat uses sonar to hunt at night. The small mammal emits a series of ultrasonic cries and listens carefully to the echoes that return. By determining how long it takes the sound to bounce back, the bat can figure out how far away its prey is.

Aaron Corcoran and William Conner of Wake Forest previously discovered Bertholdia trigona defends itself by jamming its predators’ sonar. Conner, a professor of biology, said the tiger moth has a blister of cuticle on either side of its thorax called a tymbal. It flexes this structure to create a high-pitched, clicking sound. The moth emits more than 4,500 clicks per second right when the bat would normally attack, jamming its sonar. ‘It is the only animal in the world we know of that can jam its predator’s sonar,’ Conner said. ‘Bats and tiger moths are in the midst of an evolutionary arms race.’

The new study, published May 6 in the journal PLOS ONE, shows that tiger moths can tell when it is time to start clicking by listening for a telltale change in the repetition rate of the bat’s cries and an increase in sound intensity. The combination of these two factors tells the moth that it has been targeted. Conner’s team used high-speed infrared cameras to create 3D maps of the flight paths of bats attacking tiger moths. They then used an ultrasonic microphone to measure the rate of bat cries and moth clicks.

Normally, a bat attack starts with relatively intermittent cries. As it gets closer to the moth, a bat increases the rate at which it produces cries —painting a clearer picture of the moth’s location. Conner’s team found that soon after the bats detected and targeted their prey, moths increased their rate of clicking dramatically, causing the predators to veer off course. The sonar jamming works 93 percent of the time. When the tymbal is removed, Conner says the bat will catch the tiger moth 83 percent of the time. He said this is the first quantitative study to show an animal can trigger defensive behaviors by measuring ultrasonic signals provided by predators during an attack” (source).

Image 1 for article titled "A Species of Tiger Moth Is the Only Animal that Can Jam the Sonar of a Predator"
Bertholdia trigona. The possibility that moths jam bat echolocation arose with an experiment report published in 1965 by Dorothy Dunning and Kenneth Roeder. In subsequent years, Dunning conducted further experiments to show that moth clicks serve a warning function. That is, they communicate to bats that the moths are toxic, as many moths accumulate toxic chemicals from their host plants as caterpillars and keep them in their tissues through adulthood. The first study to conclusively demonstrate that moths jam bats was published in 2009 by researchers at Wake Forest University. In this study, big brown bats were raised in captivity to ensure they had no prior experience with clicking prey and were trained to attack moths tethered to a thin line attached to the ceiling in an indoor flight room. Over a nine-night experiment, the bats attacked soundless control moths and clicking Bertholdia trigona – moths that were selected for their extraordinary clicking abilities. Bats had substantial difficulty catching the clicking moths compared to silent controls, and ate the B. trigona moths when they had the opportunity, thus refuting the hypothesis that the clicks were warning the bats of moths’ toxicity. Moth clicks also disrupted the stereotypical pattern of the bats echolocation, confirming the clicks’ jamming function (Wikipedia: Echolocation jamming in animals)

Please follow and like us: